Donut Shops in Bay Shore, New York
Looking for the best donuts in Bay Shore? You've come to the right place! We've gathered 7 of the most beloved donut shops in Bay Shore, New York, each offering their own unique take on everyone's favorite breakfast treat.
From classic glazed donuts to creative artisanal varieties, these Bay Shore donut shops serve up fresh, delicious treats daily. Each shop has been rated by local donut enthusiasts, helping you find the perfect spot for your morning coffee and donut run.

North Fork Doughnut Co. Bay Shore
5 E Main St, Bay Shore, New York
North Fork Doughnut Co. is praised for its delicious and varied donuts, with standout flavors like Maple Bacon and Cannoli. The shop offers a welcoming atmosphere with friendly service and clean environment. Despite higher prices and limited parking options, customers find the quality worth it.

Dunkin'
1403 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore, New York
Customers generally appreciate Dunkin Donuts for its excellent coffee and quick service, highlighting that staff is friendly and efficient. However, some have noted cleanliness issues with food handling, which can be concerning for health-conscious patrons. The store offers a variety of dining options from breakfast to desserts, catering well to different crowd types including families and tourists.

Dunkin'
529 E Main St, Bay Shore, New York
Dunkin' offers convenient mobile ordering and consistently fresh donuts and coffee, particularly praised for iced coffee and friendly service. The East Islip location is noted for quick service but sometimes criticized for cleanliness and preparation errors in delivery. While the store provides a clean environment and quick service, some customers have experienced issues with order quality during delivery. Overall, Dunkin' serves as a popular choice for breakfast and solo dining, with positive remarks on staff friendliness.

Dunkin'
Gas Station, 195 Pine Aire Dr, Bay Shore, New York
The Dunkin' Donuts location within the gas station receives mixed reviews with commendations for its great coffee and friendly staff, though some patrons highlight concerns over customer service and order accuracy. The establishment offers a variety of services including curbside pickup, delivery, takeout, and onsite options but lacks dine-in facilities.

Dunkin'
1261 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, New York
Dunkin' Donuts on 1261 Sunrise Highway offers excellent service and friendly staff, with some inconsistency reported in drink preparation quality. The environment is clean and the service is generally fast. Some customers have had negative experiences due to rude staff members or issues with their orders.

Dunkin'
19 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore, New York
The business receives mixed reviews regarding service quality and product offerings. While some customers praise the consistent drink preparation at one location, others express dissatisfaction with poor service, long wait times, and attitude issues among staff. The establishment is popular for its coffee and desserts, providing a variety of dining options including breakfast and takeout services.

Dunkin'
1750 5th Ave, Bay Shore, New York
Customers have mixed feelings about this Dunkin' location. While some appreciate the cleanliness and calm atmosphere, others are frustrated with long wait times and mistakes in orders. Many reviewers express dissatisfaction with staff performance and food quality. Issues like cockroaches and poor management further tarnish its reputation.