Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop logo

Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop

(4.7)

727 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, New York

Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop storefront

Summary

The donut shop is celebrated for its excellent and flavorful donuts like the Blueberry Buttermilk and Maple varieties, along with fast friendly service in a clean environment. While they offer a diverse menu including breakfast items and coffee, customers should be aware of limited parking options and high prices. Cash-only payments are required, and there's no mention of vegan or gluten-free options.

Pros

  • excellent maple donuts
  • fast friendly service
  • clean environment
  • diverse menu offerings
  • delicious coffee

Cons

  • limited parking
  • high prices
  • cash only payments

About

Old-school bakery with counter seating for donuts & pastries, plus shakes & egg creams.

Features

Coffee Available
Breakfast Items
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in
Wheelchair Accessible

Hours

monday4:30AM-6PM
tuesday4:30AM-6PM
wednesday4:30AM-6PM
thursday4:30AM-7PM
friday4:30AM-7PM
saturday5AM-7PM
sunday5:30AM-6PM

Location

Other Donut Shops Nearby

Dunkin' logo

Dunkin'

3.6

643 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, New York

The reviews for the business indicate mixed experiences with service and food quality. Customers enjoyed the fresh donuts and quick service but were disappointed by incorrect orders and limited options. The presence of homeless individuals negatively impacted some customers' perceptions. Accessibility features are well-maintained, contributing to a positive experience for those in need.

Moe's Doughs logo

Moe's Doughs

4.6

126 Nassau Ave, Brooklyn, New York

The bakery offers a variety of high-quality donuts with unique flavors like knafeh pistachio and red velvet cake. Reviews highlight the exceptional taste and freshness of their offerings, though some find them overly sweet. The staff is friendly and the environment cozy. While there are many positives, some customers feel certain donuts lack softness. Despite good service options, high prices and parking issues are concerns.

Dunkin' logo

Dunkin'

3.9

893 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, New York

This Dunkin' location is well-regarded for its consistency and service quality, especially noted by repeat customers who appreciate the friendly atmosphere. However, there are concerns about slow service during busy periods which can lead to missed appointments like train schedules. The coffee's taste has been a point of criticism, described as weak by some patrons.

Tim Hortons logo

Tim Hortons

3.8

497 Meeker Ave, Brooklyn, New York

The business is praised for its excellent coffee and fast service, with customers enjoying the breakfast options and quality of food like donuts and sandwiches. However, some disappointment arises from limited offerings such as no iced capps and being located in less appealing gas stations. Despite these drawbacks, it caters well to solo diners and tourists.

Dunkin' logo

Dunkin'

4.0

356 McGuinness Blvd, Brooklyn, New York

The establishment offers a mix of commendable and disappointing experiences based on customer feedback. Customers appreciate the friendly service, cleanliness, fresh coffee, and great atmosphere. However, issues such as moldy bread and high prices have been noted negatively. There are concerns about staff attitude and inconsistent store opening hours.

Dunkin' logo

Dunkin'

3.5

182 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, New York

The business offers a pleasant experience with fast and friendly service, alongside clean premises and delicious treats such as maple donuts. However, some customers have encountered issues with staff behavior that appears inconsistent, particularly regarding racial bias. Order fulfillment errors, specifically forgetting ordered items, are also noted by multiple reviews.

Doughnut Plant logo

Doughnut Plant

4.4

198 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, New York

The donut shop offers a variety of creative and consistently fresh doughnuts with friendly service. It provides several vegan options and features great coffee, particularly cold brew with low acidity. The atmosphere is casual with artsy seating arrangements, making it a family-friendly spot. Despite its positives, the establishment has limited parking options.

Dunkin' logo

Dunkin'

3.5

527 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, New York

The Dunkin' location is praised for its large space and fresh-tasting coffee compared to other nearby locations. However, some customers report issues with service speed, cleanliness, and staff understanding of English. There are also concerns about order accuracy, particularly regarding dietary preferences like almond milk. Despite these negatives, the store offers a variety of services including takeout, delivery, and dine-in options.